We have a winner!

4 06 2010

Hello everyone!

Thanks for giving me the opportunity to judge this round of Cook the Books. For one thing, it has taken the pressure off my own entry and for another I got to really think about the wonderful entries that everyone else put in.

I’m really impressed by the dishes that everyone was inspired to make! Such variety. And nobody could accuse them of being stodgy, boring or bland, which seem to be the criticisms usually laid at British food’s door.

So – to the judging.

In 3rd place is Claudia from Honey From Rock with her take on Sticky Toffee Pudding. I find STP very cloying usually, but her variations on the fruit sounded just wonderful, and less sweet. Plus the booze she added to the sauce makes it reminiscent of Tipsy Tart, which is my favourite South African dessert. Her pudding looks delicious and her post was a great read – with a playful tone that fit the tone of the book perfectly.

In 2nd place is Heather, the girlichef, with her fish & chips. I have often said that my last meal before they take me out and shoot me will be fish and chips, and it would be hard to beat Heather’s lovely version in a light ale batter. And as Nigel Slater wrote in the book, the smell of malt vinegar on hot chips really is “the smell of Britain”. We have a very good chippy down the street from us, and on a Friday night the queue will be out the door with people waiting for their battered haddock, and streams of people clutching their white paper parcels (not newspaper anymore) walking the other way. Heather really captured the essence of a fish supper in her post. Lovely!

And the winner is the Chicken Tikka Masala from Joanne at Eats Well With Others. If Heather’s post was the typical old-fashioned British meal, Joanne’s is the epitome of modern British food. A bit of spice (but not too much), fresh herbs and tender chicken. This dish has the added advantage of sounding much nicer than any I have ever had in a curry house over here! Chicken Tikka Masala may not look British or sound British, but apparently 23 millions portions of the stuff are sold a year in restaurants, so this is absolutely the perfect representation of British food for Cook the Books!

Thanks again for letting me judge this one.




7 responses

4 06 2010

Yay, congrats ladies – way to go Joanne!

4 06 2010


5 06 2010

Woo Hoo…honorable mentions make me smile, too 😉 Congratulations Joanne…now I really MUST try tikka masala!! Thanks for being our judge, FC!! Okay…back to my book…

5 06 2010

Congratulations Joanne! Tikka Masala does sound terrific and thank you to Foodycat for your great commentary and judging of this round of Cook the Books!

5 06 2010
Can't Believe We Ate...

Congrats Joanne!! I had no idea, but I’m glad you did, because we love Tikka Masala! Now I can serve it and call it Brit! Congrats as well to Heather…I had a shot at some last night…think I’ll cook some!…and Claudia as well! Both sounded like marvelous dishes!
Thanks again to FC for judging! See you all here for the next round!

6 06 2010

Awww thanks so much Alicia! And thanks you guys for your super sweet comments. I’m blushing!

10 06 2010

Congrats Joanne! Your tikka masala rocked. Great judging Foodycat and wonderful hosting Jo. A fun CTB round for sure!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: